TL;DR: Dividing personal property in probate is often one of the most emotional and conflict-filled parts of the process, requiring the executor to act with fairness, neutrality, and strict adherence to the decedent’s wishes—not personal preferences. The process begins with creating a detailed inventory and valuing items, then follows a structured approach: Distribute items according to the will or personal property list, fairly divide remaining items among beneficiaries, sell unclaimed valuables, donate what’s left, and discard anything without value. Disputes are common, especially with sentimental items, so having a clear plan—or even better, specific instructions in the will—can prevent conflict. The key takeaway: Ultimately, the executor’s role is to manage the process of disposing the deceased’s personal property carefully, avoid self-dealing, and ensure all decisions are handled transparently and in the best interest of the estate.
In many cases, the division and distribution of the tangible personal property in a Decedent’s Estate is one of the most contentious issues to settle in a Probate. This article will explain the reasons why this is so challenging and discuss some of the important issues that need to be considered. This article is written from the perspective of advising the Executor in the Estate in carrying out his or her Fiduciary Duties. The Executor of the estate must manage the personal property and ensure it is handled according to the deceased’s wishes and in compliance with Arizona probate laws. The Executor is not “Santa Clause”. I have seen cases where the Executor wants to give a particular item to a particular person for a particular reason. The Executor does not have the authority to distribute items according to his or her wishes. Such items must be distributed according to the wishes of the Decedent. And, in many cases, the Decedent’s wishes are expressed in general terms, and not specific terms, or sometimes not at all.
The first duty of an Executor is to create a comprehensive inventory of tangible personal property. Things like jewelry and artwork should be valued so that everyone has the same information. Assigning values to many items of personal property can be contentious, as family members may have differing opinions on their economic worth. And certainly, some may have more of a sentimental value than others. This can be a challenge in some cases, especially if there are no clear records or documentation. This case comes to mind: The Decedent leaves a Will that says that all of his personal belongings go to his three children. Yet, the Decedent has a Surviving Spouse. Who gets the TV, or the Stereo? Did it belong to the Decedent, or to the Surviving Spouse? What if the Surviving Spouse says that her husband or wife gave that item to him or her just prior to death? No easy answers here, but in this case, I believe that “possession is nine-tenths of the law” and the Surviving Spouse wins that dispute.
What if I gave Dad a very expensive piece of art and Dad dies? Should I get that back or is it part of the division of personal belongings that Dad gave to all of his kids? From a legal standpoint, I gave it to Dad, and it should be part of the division. However, from an emotional standpoint, that piece of art was special to me and my dad and it was extremely expensive. It should come back to me, right? Well, that may sound morally right, but it certainly isn’t legally right.
In the perfect scenario, the Decedent left a “Tangible Personal Property List” attached to the Will. This makes it easy to know what the Decedent’s wishes were as to the “big ticket items” like the Remington Bronze discussed below. This list should dispose of not only items of economic value but also items of sentimental value.
Once we have an inventory of the items to be disposed of, then follow these five steps in order:
- Distribute according to the Will or Personal Property List as described above.
- Come up with a fair division of the remaining items that the heirs want.
- Have an Estate Sale.
- Donate to Charity.
- Deposit in a Dumpster.
It is difficult for people when preparing their Will to decide which child gets which item(s). I think of our Remington Bronze which is located in our family room. The one that is entitled “Coming through the Rye”, depicting four drunk cowboys on their horses. Every one of our five kids grew up with this item in our living room. Talking to our kids, every one of them wants this as a priority item for them. This is a very difficult item of personal property because it has both economic value and sentimental value. Which one of our kids will get it?
Deciding who should receive which items can lead to conflicts among beneficiaries. Emotions are always at their highest when we lose a loved one. Because there is only one “Coming through the Rye”, only one person is going to be happy and four others are going to be mad. These items are extremely difficult to divide because of the sentimental value, as well as the economic value. Another example is when my dad died, there was a real emotional battle over the water dipper that hung in our cabin for years that everyone drank out of as kids. It had no economic value but had really high sentimental value.
There are many ways that disputes over Personal Property in Probate can be resolved. But one that I recommend the most is to place all of the pieces of personal property that need to be divided on the floor for everyone in the family to see. If there are five kids, then you decide who is going to pick first. Our family resolved the water dipper fight by simply playing one of my grandkids’ favorite games: “one potato, two potato, three potato, four”. Whoever won that game went first and chose an item and could assign their own sentimental value to that item. Then the next oldest child got to pick first in round two. There are countless other ways to do it, but you get the idea. The best way to resolve the dispute is to describe the method in which the items will be chosen inside of your Last Will and Testament. In Wills drafted by our law firm, we resolve the dispute by simply saying that the kids have 4 months to agree, and if they can’t agree, then the item is to be sold and added to the “residue of the Estate”.
Items that have some economic value, but are of no interest to the kids, should be sold at an Estate Sale. There are many professionals that will perform this service for you. If there are only a few items, and they can be easily valued, then you can conduct the Estate Sale yourself. Remember, the Executor has a duty to maximize the Estate Assets.
After that, any remaining items of value can be donated to Charity. Try to pick a Charity or Charities that had meaning to the Decedent.
After all four steps mentioned above are complete, then you are down to the final step, the dumpster. Remember, Charities want something of value that they can sell or have a personal need for within the Charity. They don’t want assets that are going to take them time and effort to dispose of for very low or no economic value at all.
The most important thing to remember as the Executor is that you have fiduciary duties of fairness and impartiality. You also have a duty to avoid a personal conflict of interest by giving such personal belongings to yourself. It’s crucial for you as the Executor to work together with the family and, if necessary, seek legal guidance to address these issues effectively during the Arizona probate process.